Freedom is a human right, and we are committed to defending it even when others won’t

illustration of ProtonMail free speech

Since we launched in 2014, ProtonMail has been the preferred email service provider for activists around the world. Protecting freedom of speech and democracy is, after all, one of the main reasons we created ProtonMail in the first place. Normally, this would not be of particular interest to anyone: we have always believed that all citizens deserve the right to privacy, and we maintain neutrality on most political matters. 

But the decision by some companies to bow to political pressure surrounding activists in Hong Kong, Indonesia, Catalonia, and elsewhere has suddenly made this issue controversial. Given that some of these protesters are ProtonMail users, we would like to take this opportunity to clarify our position on the use of our platform by social activists.

Rising activism around the world

Reports of activism around the world have been on the rise, and in recent months, the size and frequency of protest movements appear to have rapidly increased. It is a fact that these activists  are increasingly turning to ProtonMail. 

Examples include activists in Hong Kong, including the makers of HKmap, who are using our service to keep their communications secure. In Spain, Catalonian independence campaigners at Tsunami Democràtic have been using ProtonMail to coordinate their activities. In West Papua, the independent media activists at West Papua Media use ProtonMail to communicate with foreign journalists in response to enforced censorship by the Indonesian government. In the UK and the US, members of the climate protest group Extinction Rebellion have been using ProtonMail to organize. 

The right to peaceful protest is one of the cornerstones of democracy. The Internet has given people the tools to share ideas and coordinate their actions more easily than ever before. But equally it’s given governments the ability to shut down opposition more efficiently than at any other time in history. As a result, we believe tech companies have a responsibility to protect the essential freedoms that others have fought to gain. This doesn’t mean that we have to take a particular side in a debate, but it’s vital that we allow the debate to take place. 

Why activists choose ProtonMail

We founded ProtonMail to build an Internet that protects privacy, defends civil liberties, and keeps users safe from cyber attacks. We firmly believe in the right to free speech, the right to privacy and security, and the principle that no one should be prevented from exercising these rights. 

We believe that technology has an important role in safeguarding human rights in the 21st century. Specifically at ProtonMail, we have leveraged end-to-end encryption to protect privacy by ensuring that, on ProtonMail, only the sender and recipient can read user messages. No third party, no government, and not even us, can abuse ProtonMail to spy on user communications, thus enabling the privacy which forms the foundation of freedom of speech.

Because the technology behind our service protects against surveillance and government harassment, ProtonMail is the preferred platform for journalists, investigators, and human rights groups, particularly those working in high-risk environments. Because of our strong belief in the need to protect freedom of speech for all, we have also endeavored to go above and beyond to protect Proton’s most sensitive users from both cybercriminals and governments what would seek to deny these rights. This is a moral obligation that we feel all companies should seek to uphold, but this has unfortunately not been the case.

There is a long history of companies bowing to political or social pressure to protect their access to markets. We’ve seen Google filtering results in certain territories where censorship is legal, and more recently we’ve seen Apple store data in China and remove apps created by protesters, including the HKmap app developed by one of our users in Hong Kong. 

At ProtonMail, we’ve taken a different approach that honors both political neutrality and the belief that the rights of privacy and free speech should apply to everyone.

We support peaceful protest and access to privacy

Proton is a Swiss company, which means we operate under Swiss law and only Swiss law. Therefore, users are protected by Switzerland’s strong rule of law: foreign law enforcement requests must be approved by a Swiss court before we can be compelled to act on them. When protesters use ProtonMail, we don’t take a position for or against the protest, only that we support the right to peacefully protest.

We do, however, take a position on the right to privacy, security, and freedom of speech. We firmly believe that everyone, no matter where they live or what they believe, has a right to express their ideas peacefully in public and privately online. We have also supported various causes ourselves, from a face surveillance moratorium to net neutrality.

Finally, it is important to note that the use of ProtonMail is not unconditional. We have clear terms and conditions that prohibit activity that would be illegal in Switzerland, such as hate speech or destruction of property. Breaking these rules will result in accounts being disabled. If a Swiss court rules that your usage of ProtonMail is illegal, this would also result in your account being shut down, as we must abide by all applicable Swiss laws. 

We’re proud that our platform is being used by activists as a means of communicating, staying safe, and getting their voices heard. Everyone has the right to privacy, whether they are a campaigner or a regular member of the public, and ProtonMail is happy to provide the means for this to happen. There are no factors, political or economic, which can lead us to compromise this core value.

Best regards,
The ProtonMail Team

About ProtonMail
ProtonMail is the world’s largest secure email service. Founded in Geneva in 2014 by scientists who met at the European Centre for Nuclear Research (CERN), ProtonMail protects over 10 million users, including journalists, activists, doctors, lawyers, businesses, and ordinary citizens who want email that is both safer and more private. Because messages are end-to-end encrypted, we cannot read your emails, sell your data to advertisers or compromise the privacy of your communications. ProtonMail is email as it should be — private and secure.

You can get a free secure email account from ProtonMail here.

We also provide a free VPN service to protect your privacy.

ProtonMail and ProtonVPN are funded by community contributions. If you would like to support our development efforts, you can upgrade to a paid plan or donate. Thank you for your support.

About the Author

Andy Yen

Andy is the Founder and CEO of ProtonMail. Originally from Taiwan, he is a long time advocate of privacy rights and has spoken at TED, SXSW, and the Asian Investigative Journalism Conference about online privacy issues. Previously, Andy was a research scientist at CERN and received his PhD in Particle Physics from Harvard University. You can watch his TED talk online to learn more about ProtonMail's mission.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

7 comments on “Freedom is a human right, and we are committed to defending it even when others won’t

  • Hello, I’ve read this article of yours and I think you should correct it.

    Tsunami Democrátic is not an activist group, it is an extremely violent ultra-left and nationalist group that has been charged by Spanish judges for alleged crimes of terrorism, street violence, attempted homicide, vandalism, among other multiple crimes.

    Here you can read the news:

    https://elpais.com/elpais/2019/09/27/inenglish/1569568870_128248.html
    https://elpais.com/elpais/2019/10/19/inenglish/1571484159_002176.html

    Therefore, they do not use protonmail to coordinate their activism but rather their criminal organization.

    I hope that you will correct it since you say that you do not support violence.

    Reply
    • The articles you cited don’t support your statement. Moreover, we would not follow the ruling of a Spanish judge because we are a Swiss company.

      Reply
  • Thus been against Tsunamic Democratic (his goals) and the catalonian independent movement as I’m from Spain and I follow the details of the situation (btw what they want would be also illegal on Switzerland), but that not mean at all that I’m against of his use from ProtonMail, as you said is a Human right the privacy on ther comunication and protest pacefully, and I’m sadly certain that in cases like this Spain or other European countries would spy them, and they SHOULDN’T!

    Reply
  • Two Catalan pro-independence former members of parliament, Anna Gabriel and Marta Rovira, live in exile in Switzerland fleeing Spanish political persecution, this proves that Switzerland is a country that will protect activists fighting for democracy and Protonmail made the right decision establishing their headquarters there.

    Reply
  • “We do, however, take a position on the right to privacy, security, and freedom of speech.”

    “prohibit activity that would be illegal in Switzerland, such as hate speech or destruction of property.”

    Free speech and hate speech are two separate things? Free speech means you can say anything and not be held legally accountable. Hate speech feels certain speech is essentially illegal and forbidden. ProtonMail, you need to pick one. Are you for free speech or not? Cause if your not, your going to lose many customers and be consider politically biased.

    Reply
    • Hate speech is illegal under Art. 261 and 261bis of the Swiss criminal code and related case law. As a company based in Switzerland, we are required to comply with Swiss law.

      Reply
  • @Carlos

    Your links to an ultra nationalist Spanish newspaper do not prove anything, it is hillarious seeing you trying to pass off as real the information that a biased fake news Spanish nationalist newspaper publishes.

    If we stick to facts we can see that Spain, besides using violence to stop Catalan people from voting in a referendum and sentincing peaceful Catalan politicians to 13 years in prison for organising a referendum, it is as well the only country in the World where Tsunami Democratic is illegal, nowhere else in the European Union, USA, Switzerland, etc have a problem with Tsunami Democratic.

    It is always funny to see how Spanish nationalists claim that their country is right and everybody else in the World is wrong. Spain is a democracy as much as it is Turkey, as long as you are not Kurdish or Catalan, you have the right to protest, otherwise jail awaits you.

    Reply